Site icon Sparrowfare

Defending the Unmeasurable in a Calculating Age

“To define knowledge as merely empirical is to limit one’s ability to know; it enfeebles one’s ability to feel and think.”

This is Wendell Berry’s assertion in Life is a Miracle: An Essay Against Modern Superstition, an impassioned defense–written at the beginning of the 21st century–of the unquantifiable mysteries found in art, nature, religion, tradition, and human community.

The superstition in the book’s subtitle is the reductionist insistence that everything seen and unseen can be reduced to material quantities (or could, if we had the tools). Reductionism turns science into scientism that “simply rules out or blots out whatever it can’t explain or doesn’t like.”

It can’t abide a mystery.

Berry (who passed away at 92 after a lifetime of literary creation and environmental activism) was deeply concerned about the scientistic tendency, especially among academics, to exclude from discussions of value whatever can’t be detected and quantified using scientific and mathematical tools.

Reductionism greatly constricts our understanding of reality as a whole.

We begin to value only what can be measured.

Things that can be measured are a wonderful part of the world, and measurement well used can inform our decisions in positive ways, helping us better care for and cooperate with the physical world.

But the tools of math and science can also be used to create food that doesn’t nourish, to reduce education to test taking competencies, and to extract commercial benefit from or even to gain power over nature without concern for the worth of the things that cannot be measured.

So we must be measured about our use of measurement because it can make us forgetful of the things that can’t be measured.

Berry is particularly wary of the way money trumps mystery because it can be quantified, and in a reductionist world this lowers the value of of the unmeasurable. “There is a kind of egalitarianism which holds that any two things equal in price are equal in value,” he writes, “and that nothing is better than anything that may profitably or fashionably replace it:

Forest = field = parking lot; if the price of alteration is right, then there is no point in quibbling over differences. One place is as good as another, one use is as good as another, one life is as good as another—if the price is right.

Reductionism leads to the pushy pride of endless growth because growth can be measured; it has no humility about the rest of creation but only about its use, ignoring the fact that that value can’t be measured only at the bank.

I’m reminded of the time a friend of mine overheard a conversation in a restaurant with a picture window overlooking a stunning mountain view in southern Colorado–lush, green and teeming with wildlife.

A couple on vacation was seated at a table near him. As the two gazed at the majestic view through the window, my friend heard the woman comment, “This is beautiful. Somebody ought to do something with it.”

I don’t know what she thought should be done with all that beauty, but the earth has been razed so much that my friend couldn’t resist thinking cynically about that remark.

Doze it, develop it, do something with it and then it will be worth something.

Which of course does not mean we never develop anything. Berry farmed the Kentucky land of his heritage and that is development. We need roads and homes and places to buy the other things we need to live. Must this obvious truth be established each time we make the case for things that can’t be measured? To plea that developers take into consideration values that can’t be plugged into a calculator as well as things that can?

Paul Kingsnorth’s provocative Against the Machine: On the Unmaking of Humanity considers this and much more. Kingsnorth, the English writer and thinker now living in west Ireland, has taken Berry’s thesis and run with it. Observing where reductionist thinking has led humanity in the 21st century, he exposes how industry, commerce and the politics of both the left and the right have exponentially reduced human activity and all created beauty to the kind of measurable, data-driven economic categories and performance goals that now influence everything from algorithmic shopping suggestions to the green movement itself.

Against the Machine is a wide ranging reflection on the ways social movements, commerce and political ideologies have undermined humanity by attacking or diminishing the importance of four “P’s” that defy measurement–past, people, place, and prayer. These things provide unmeasurable meaning to human life. They ground us in a story.

We now seem to be telling ourselves a different kind of story from the stories that humankind told in various ways throughout history.

It is a story that minimizes the unquantifiable “P’s” and elevates progress, growth, human comfort and endless options over the roots and limits that have kept humanity both grounded in the physical and open to the transcendent at the same time.

Kingsnorth believes that reductionist ideology paired with global capitalism (as opposed to local free market economies) is driving this other story, flattening and absorbing the ideologies of both left and right, fitting them both into an empirical-only mindset that lauds measures and minimizes the human values that defy quantification.

He asks us to consider the value of things that can’t be measured. Even the short list in his book is enough to lift the heart and remind the soul of unmeasurable things we must keep defending.

The things which cannot be measured happen to be the stuff of life. Love. God. Place. Culture. The profound mystery of beauty. A sense of being rooted. A feeling for land or community or cultural traditions or the unfolding of human history over generations. Song. Art.

“They’ll ‘datafy’ all of this soon enough, no doubt, or try to,” Kingsnorth wryly predicts. (One of the charms of his book is its sardonic humor.) “But the kind of people who think that the Great Library of Alexandria contained ‘exabytes’ worth of information’ rather than the collected fruits of hard-won wisdom are lost before they ever sit down to their datasets.”

Kingsnorth quotes Wendell Berry in Against the Machine’s epigraph. Back when the internet was new and before the invention of the smartphone and artificial intelligence, Wendell Berry wrote, “It is easy for me to imagine that the next great division of the world will be between people who wish to live as creatures and people who wish to live as machines.”

I wish to live as a creature, and I bet you do too. To even remember we are creatures while we discern how to live in a world that increasingly excludes things that can’t be measured in its projects and plans is the challenge of our time.

Berry called us to “watch, refine our intelligence and our attention, curb our greed and our pride, work with care, have faith.”

Have faith. St. Paul’s exalted blessing in his letter to the Ephesians uses the categories of measurement to remind us of immeasurable love of God: “that you, being rooted and grounded in love,  may have power to comprehend with all the saints what is the breadth and length and height and depth,  and to know the love of Christ which surpasses knowledge, that you may be filled with all the fulness of God.”

That fulness can neither be accessed nor measured by a machine. It is sought in the unquantifiable human heart.

Please share Sparrowfare, and if you enjoyed this post I’d be most grateful if you’d subscribe here.

Where do you see important human activities being reduced to quantifiable data? I’d love to hear from you!

You might also enjoy Galileo’s Daughter Meets God and the Astronomers and Nature’s Best Hope: Your Back Yard and Mine.

“When efficiency becomes the ultimate measure of value, human beings are tempted to see themselves as a project to be optimized rather than as persons called to relationship and communion.” Pope Leo’s encyclical Magnificent Humanity (Magnifica Humanitas): On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligenceapplies the humane principles of Catholic Social Teaching to the challenges presented by the exponential growth of artificial intelligence. While summarizing the rich benefits this new technology is already bringing, he calls us to remember the things that preserve our common humanity: wisdom, authentic culture and art, service and compassion.

Photos by Liana S and Martin Katler on Unsplash. Scripture reference: Ephesians 3:18–19, RSV. This Rich Mullins song applies it as only a poet can.

Exit mobile version